I actually like this cookie because it gives me a real sugar rush. The cookie, although pumpkin shaped and covered with orange-colored icing, does not taste of pumpkin nor of orange. Its just a very basic sugar cookie covered with icing. I am guessing that the taste is similar to the Half Moon cookie. I also like that it is a single, although large, cookie per pack and 1 cookie satisfies my sugar craving. At 99 cents, I would give it as a Halloween treat, since I have very few trick or treat-ers.